Columnists

Most Comments

Peanut Gallery

Not My Tribe on Facebook
Tweets from Not My Tribe
Second Life
Boycott Israeli Goods Granma essays of Fidel Castro
Click to buy St Patricks Day parade t-shirts
Click for more on COLORADANS FOR PEACE

Pantheon of Heroes

Bradley Manning
GI Wikileaker
Massimo Tartaglia
Berlusconi pugilist
Muntadhar al-Zaidi
shoe thrower
Tim DeChristopher
Bidder 70
Glenn Spagnuolo
R68 rabblerouser
Andrew Meyer
Don't taser me Bro
Rachel Corrie
Palestinian rights
Ken O'Keefe
Human shield

Rapscallions

Adrian Lamo
Informant
James O'Keefe, fraud
Hannah Giles, fraud
Brandon Darby, FBI informant
Neda Agha-Soltan, *
Yoani Sanchez, fiction
John Yettaw, spoiler
Rebecca Joseph, UCSB Tova Hausman, UCSB Greg Mortenson, tool Prince Harry
wannabe killer
Scott Robinson
RNC Kicker

Popular Culture

Book reviews:
Three Cups of Tea -- 1000 White Women - Harry Potter dead zone
Zorro
Film reviews:
Dolores Umbrage Bush Twilight - Happy Feet -
The Queen - King Kong
Borat

Essays:
Homer for gen. Simpson
The authoritarian M.O.
Plastic flower of youth

—- Internets —

NotMyTribe banner for general distribution
Colorado Springs Progressive Blogs
Local coverage of the arts on SPRINGS CULTURE CAST
Newspeak Moblog
Blog News Net Colorado Lefty Blogs Lefty Blogs Boycott AP Lewis Links Riseup dot net Add to Technorati Favorites Creative Commons License Let iCab Smile
Not My Tribe 60×60 button
Check PageRank Site Meter TECHNORATI auth488 COMPETE 102K QUANTCAST 57K URLFAN 148K WS.OUTLOOK 362K
Free Bradley Manning Left List US IWW Wobblies Socialist Party aim-native-american-indian-movement-peace-sign.gif Troublemakers Union Organic Consumers Association ACORN EZLN Black is Back

Reference Library

NMT Calendar

APRIL 2010
19-25 - Week of Solidarity with Latin America
22- CC lecture: Paul Watson

MAY 2010
1- International Workers Day
4- Day of Solidarity with the People of Nicaragua
15- Day of Solidarity with Palestine
22-29 Week of Solidarity with Africa

JUNE 2010
6- Anniversary of Israeli seizure of Gaza
20- International Day of Disarmament
25-26 G-20 summit, Huntsville, Ontario

JULY 2010
26- Day of World Solidarity with the Cuban Revolution

AUG 2010
3- Day of World Solidarity with the Struggle of the People of Guinea-Bissau and the Cape Verde Islands
6- Day of World Solidarity with the Struggle of the Japanese People
18- Day of Solidarity with the Afro-American People

SEPT 2010
12- Day of Solidarity with the People of Zimbabwe
21- UN International Day of Peace, sponsors PTP, UF & CPI
23- Day of Solidarity with the People of Puerto Rico
25- Day of Solidarity with the People of Mozambique
30-10/6 - Week of Solidarity with the Peoples of Asia

OCT 2010
8- Day of the Heroic Guerrilla
10- Indigenous Peoples Day
12- Day of Solidarity with Laos
19- International Media Democracy Day

Interests

Watching

Live #jan25 coverage on Al-Jazeera and PressTV
 

The War on Islam’s covert battlefield: Yemen.

Coup Accomplit: Obama’s decap of Honduras.

Trending Keywords: Pox Americana, War Czar

Get our RSS feed

Search articles

Archives


Interesting Feeds

RSS The Rag Blog

RSS Black Agenda Report

RSS Space 4 Peace

RSS Antiwar.com

RSS Global Research

RSS Infoshop

RSS Angry Arab

RSS Monkey Smashes Heaven

RSS Propublica

RSS Media Matters

RSS Colorado Media Matters

Latest Articles

Links:

Does NPR have a hiring impediment?

Louisa Lim National Public RadioNATIONAL PUBLIC RADIO- I can laugh at speech impediments with the best of them. But I’m less comfortable if there’s no laugh track. Specifically, when it’s a speech-challenged news reporter, I utterly object to being made to decipher from mispronunciation. On the radio, poor diction is as unacceptable as inaudible recording, and disabled- enunciation is as appropriate as a paraplegic delivering your piano. Take NPR’s Louisa Lim.

Give someone a job they can handle, but don’t celebrate equal opportunity without consideration for the task required.

Louisa Lim can’t pronounce her Rs. Might not someone have thought to counsel Lim fwom puhsuing a caweeuh on the wadio? Dropped Rs represent an alphabet 1/26th deficient. More, if you adjust inversely by Scrabble point value.

Monte Python’s Pontius Pilate of Life of Brian was mocked by the chorus for not being able to say his R’s. And yes, his Roman audience found the hilarity unending. It’s why he was urged to release Bawabas and not Jesus. Gilda Radner similarly mocked Barbara Walters. Mispwonouncing her Rs didn’t keep Bahbwa Wahwah from a lengthy career, but that’s the point I’m coming to.

If speech impediments were congenital, it would still be no reason to exhibit them center-stage like cultural accents.

Aren’t most speaking disorders remedied in the primary grades, given extra attention from speech therapists? Why do the exceptions seem to become Communications Majors? It’s as if students who have reason to work on their locution, end up becoming the professionals.

But choirs don’t tolerate tone-deafness, why would broadcasters burden themselves with mis-speakers?

Louisa Lim can’t say R, but she’s only one of a majority of female voices on NPR hobbled by flawed presentation. Don’t you find that strange? Considering that Amy Goodman’s delivery is criticized for being shrill. It’s as if NPR thinks strong feminine voices would come across as too authoritative, unless a physical weakness is empirically discernible. Would this explain why most the female voices on NPR are nasal, or supported by the weakest lung capacity? Their tiny voices sound like they could extinguish themselves without the next breath. Audiences like it too obviously.

Accents too, foreign and domestic, work to temper the projection of authority. Male presenters traditionally have sported commanding voices. Today, those who don’t moderate for sporting events most often have voices in the higher registers, or modulate their voices with rises in pitch which communicates timidity.

Related articles

Permalink to this article link     Submit Does NPR have a hiring impediment? to Digg.com   Bookmark Does NPR have a hiring impediment? in Reddit   Bookmark Does NPR have a hiring impediment? in Newsvine   bookmark  Does NPR have a hiring impediment? in del.icio.us   Bookmark Does NPR have a hiring impediment? in Spurl   Bookmark Does NPR have a hiring impediment? to Fark   Bookmark Does NPR have a hiring impediment? to Yahoo!   Tweet this post

Comments

Comment from Tracy Whipple   (IP: 24.10.60.66)
Time: August 21, 2012, 9:42 am

While i certainly noticed the impediment. I find Ms. Lim’s voice neither annoying nor adorable. I simply focus on the content of the report & don’t hyper-focus on her soft /r/s. I guess I am blessed with being able to stay neutral and forgive such grievous occurrences, thereby avoiding the more heinous threat to society than ‘the soft r’…’the whiny bi*ch’.

Comment from anony   (IP: 128.135.240.17)
Time: August 29, 2012, 2:11 pm

I agree about both Louisa Lim and Patti Neighmond.
If you can’t say your /r/s, you sound like a small child.
When you can’t say your /sh/s, /ch/s and /j/s without sounding like a drunk, you might want to stick to being a print journalist.

Comment from Dr Piccolo Heintz   (IP: 173.79.253.9)
Time: April 17, 2013, 7:48 pm

I have NEVER understood why radio stations, particularly NPR would even consider hiring someone with a speech impediment. It drives me nuts!!

Couldn’t NPR pay for some speech therapy lessons for Wisa Wim. My skin crawls when I hear her on the radio.

Comment from DD   (IP: 86.151.108.98)
Time: April 27, 2013, 3:51 pm

Louisa Lim you are a typical westerner who is unfamiliar with the Far East culture yet writes with your full curiously, therefore every word of yours is showing a great deal of strangeness you detected in China, you feel strange about them is because you don’t understand them and their culture. As far as I concern, your articles are lack of research and understanding, purely coming from an ignorant citizen/Tourist from the West. I also suspect she works for the CIA intending to bring down Chinese government through her keyboard…In which case, She is no professional journalist at all.

Comment from Adolf   (IP: 67.202.75.54)
Time: December 5, 2013, 1:30 pm

Don’t forget Rob Stein and Carrie Kahn

Comment from Linda P.   (IP: 74.61.0.162)
Time: December 30, 2013, 7:44 pm

And don’t forget Alix Spiegel with the breathy vocal fry and Margo Adler one of several with a very noticeable lithp.

Comment from the listener   (IP: 72.191.38.243)
Time: January 5, 2014, 12:21 pm

Oh, thank you for pointing out this annoying radio voice. Her impediment is annoying and distracting. Its difficult to take someone seriously when they sound like elmer fudd.

Comment from Tim T   (IP: 204.145.116.10)
Time: August 26, 2014, 2:57 pm

Some people have “a face for radio”. Louisa has “a voice for print”.

Comment from Pat C   (IP: 71.184.199.75)
Time: November 18, 2014, 6:31 pm

I’m hard of hearing… I’ve never noticed. Why is it important? Afwaid your kids will grow up to speak like hew?

Comment from Jefferson   (IP: 70.67.244.11)
Time: August 4, 2015, 10:05 am

It’s more of Liberalism the Mental Disorder at work here… Liberalism which puts “Equality and Fairness” ahead of “Quality and Standards”, celebrating the abnormal and Perverse is part of liberalism..

Comment from microdon2   (IP: 173.56.250.129)
Time: February 1, 2016, 5:30 pm

Jefferson (above) hit the nail on the head. The reason it’s so offensive to hear supposedly professional NPR radio reporters \ announcers with speak impediments is that it’s so obvious that it’s Liberal political correctness run amok. “What’s that – you can’t speak properly? Have an annoying lisp or can’t pronounce your “R”‘s? Of COURSE you can work as a radio reporter for us. After all, NPR is INCLUSIVE. And we’re willing to PROVE it by hiring a verbal invalid like YOU.” This is the journalistic equivalent of putting a 5ft Asian guy who can’t jump on the Olympic basketball team. The obvious Liberal message behind it is much more annoying than the actual speech defect. It’s gotten to the point where I turn the radio off as soon as I hear “Peter Overby”. (besides that he takes himself SO seriously, and he ONLY addresses socially serious topics… puke.” Can NOT stand him.

Comment from Betsy Friauf   (IP: 76.183.64.31)
Time: March 15, 2016, 12:48 pm

These remarks are narrow minded and mean spirited. Why bother posting your hate? It is not constructive. All these reporters are very good journalists. I admire them greatly for working for one of the best journalism outlets in the world, and for not letting their limitations limit their accomplishments. The fact that they have human flaws makes them better reporters; they know about struggle and can relate to others’ struggles. Remember, Beethoven was deaf when he wrote his best music.

Comment from Nm   (IP: 70.56.174.175)
Time: March 27, 2016, 2:11 pm

Rob Stein, Mo Rocca, David Edelstein can’t speak without impediments.

Comment from Pat McCann   (IP: 74.108.216.254)
Time: April 11, 2016, 3:34 pm

Betsy Friauf – YOU and your liberal, “inclusive at all costs” thinking ARE the PROBLEM. And that you don’t see that is perfect. Yes, Beethoven was deaf at the end of his life – but he produced INCREDIBLE music, in SPITE of his deafness. These reporters can NOT produce professional radio reports given their speech impediments. The fact that so many people online are complaining about it is proof of that. Can you not see THAT??

Comment from Michael C.   (IP: 206.55.185.22)
Time: April 13, 2016, 8:39 pm

I have three question for the haters (Jefferson and pat McCann) 1. Why would RW goobers like you listen to NPR? 2. Do you know the difference between an announcer and a reporter? 3. You know Rob Stein is a successful journalist and you aren’t, right?

Comment from Dawn Ducoulombier   (IP: 99.112.3.96)
Time: May 18, 2016, 2:42 pm

I enjoy listening to real people like Rob Stein, and his quality of program is exceptional. I like his lisp. He doesn’t sound like a child because of his professionalism. Just because people have slight human imperfections also know as simply being human, why should they be excluded from the employment process. I come home and read more about what they report on and find these journalists a valuable source of news and information. One of the reasons I don’t watch television news is because of the fake people hired to deliver the news. Look at the women and how they are required to look, sexy, gorgeous, above average looking people. I will stick with NPR. I also think that these people need to go back to FOX television or CNN, their people comes with no other human imperfections. Find something else to knock down.

Comment from Brother Jonah   (IP: 75.71.247.180)
Time: May 18, 2016, 6:56 pm

Hey, good you found something here. Even though this one is like 6 years ago. I think. And we do roast the Wrong Wing quite often. It’s not quite a secret that you don’t actually have to agree with Eric or me on just anything. The way this post got bumped up to the present is we were experiencing a spam attack.

In case you want to see some right wing pigs roasting then groovy. You came to the right or perhaps left place.

There’s another about Glenn Beck that Tony posted like 3 years ago. “conservative hero” which also got bumped up

I like to judge on ones best work than the worst. For most people that’s a really sweet deal. Including Eric.

With some commentators like Beck and Romney and Trump and so on, it’s unfortunately the best, on which we judge. Their “best” isn’t really distinguished from their worst. I suppose the difference comes from them being compelled to write what their bosses tell them to write. That and they’re generally Socially Retarded Animated Sphincters.

And nobody is required to agree with anybody. Even I am not placed in such a place of honor that others have to agree with me. I know that’s hard to believe, being as I am the greatest writer who ever lived and I realize it. But I don’t get conceited even though it’s richly deserved. Because Conceit is a fault and I have none.

Comment from JimmyRiot   (IP: 173.17.49.206)
Time: July 15, 2016, 2:09 pm

Yes most NPR listeners lean left like me, but come on, these guys have a point. I too can’t listen to Louisa Lim’s marble mouth (BBC’s guilty too). Peter Overby I picture looking like the creepy pencil drawings guy from Monty Python, deena TEMPLE raston whisper-rasps like she thinks she’s sexy and doesn’t want the person next to her to hear, like it’s some damn secret. Rob Stein sounds like a squirrel with cheeks filled with stored nuts. Elanore Beardsly has toned it down lately but you still hear the affected Trisha Takinawa (“Asian Correspondent” from Family Guy) voice. Kenneth Turrant? He milks that gravel so insencerely. I know because when it’s live back and forth he doesn’t milk it like when he files a report. Same w deena TEMPLE raston; I’ve heard her speak like a normal person too. Proof that for some reason they do it on purpose because they must think it’s either sexy or appealing. It’s not.

Comment from JimmyRiot   (IP: 173.17.49.206)
Time: July 15, 2016, 2:12 pm

So you’ve got the legitimate speech impediment folks, and you’ve got the milkers.

Comment from JimmyRiot   (IP: 173.17.49.206)
Time: July 15, 2016, 2:26 pm

Sorry to over-post, but I forgot the worst offender, and this will rile some of you up: Diane Reahm. I already know some of you will say “what a jerk, she has medical problems and gets ‘throat treatments'”, BUT I’ve heard her speak at a normal pace plenty of times when not doing her show, proving…..she……is…….capable…….of…….it……when….she….suspects…..it…… won’t ……..come……across……as endearing…..as…….she THINKS………..it…does………….on….her……show.

P.S. Apparently she’s very nasty to the help. I could also give a toss about her stupid dog.

Comment from Melisander Wildberger   (IP: 174.30.35.1)
Time: September 9, 2016, 6:40 pm

Though not a “speech impediment” in the usual sense, one wonders how Wolf Blitzer ever landed a job in voice communications with his inability to utter more than three or four words (always LOUDLY) without gasping for breath, which he never does at the end of a phrase, but always at the most awkward points.

Comment from Pat McCann   (IP: 173.56.250.106)
Time: March 20, 2017, 6:45 am

Latest addition to the NPR speech impediment crew – Alison Kodjak. Hers is more subtle, but just as obnoxious. I wonder what percentage of NPR’s radio personalities are verbally impaired? My guess – 35%. Isn’t that about the level to qualify for federal funding?

Comment from Brother Jonah   (IP: 75.71.247.180)
Time: March 20, 2017, 11:28 am

Rush Limbaugh and Bill O’Reilly and even well-voice-trained actor who pretended to be a Leader Ronald Reagan had a speech impediment as well. Like most right wing extremists they can’t or couldn’t open their mouths without spewing shit.

Maybe the NPR on-air “hire” people who, like me, don’t speak like movie actors. But are intelligent and actually know the subjects they report. Because NPR doesn’t have nearly the budget for paying actors to report fake news like FOX or the Talk Radio assholes.

Michael “Savage” Weiner, for instance, speaks like Beverly Sills could sing (RIP) but he actually thinks he could have a black belt in Tae Kwon Do without taking formal lessons. I checked. Unless he lied (which he does often but particularly) about his real name and birthdate and if he took any lesson at all in Tae Kwon Do he would be listed as such in two repositories one in Seoul and the other in San Francisco of people who have actually partaken of Tae Kwon Do.

John Wayne took elocution lessons to perfect the accent he used in his movies, was never a cowboy (that’s really hard labor, and low paid) and neither was Reagan or especially GW Bush. Like the Savage Weiner, they spewed simple crap out of their facial orifices and were taken seriously. I would a heap rather listen to somebody who has something intelligent to say and who understands his subject matter regardless of eloquence. In ROTC which I attended and at Military Elitist Academies which I didn’t, the cadets are given elocution training, called “bugling” which means saying something forcefully and clearly enough to allow you to tell those under your command the most outrageous lies and they will believe you. At West Point if you don’t know the answer you fake it, and the part which has a higher grade point is “are you forcible, clear, and sound confident in speech” and not actually getting the correct answer.

It’s how incompetent fucks like Custer and McCain managed to look competent even though Custer lost far more battles than he won, and McCain couldn’t fly worth shit and probably accidentally broke his final plane in that swamp near Hanoi.

Revelance? NPR has better sources, as in not habitual congenital liars, and their correspondents and reporters are actually intelligent and not pretending. They also don’t get paid nearly as much as FOX pays.

Comment from Doug   (IP: 78.193.210.86)
Time: June 24, 2017, 6:31 pm

I agree with the blog. Untrained voices like those NPR hires are distracting. In some cases, like Rob Stein, they are blood-curdling. The sound of their voices is like a combination between fingernails on a chalk board and a baby crying. it is impossible to ignore — and i am partially deaf!!!
I know rob Stein is a talented journalist. He should stick with print and let a trained voice actor read his pieces.

Comment from Allen   (IP: 73.40.165.8)
Time: September 11, 2017, 10:59 am

It’s not just the NPR people. It goes all the way from the local news stations all the way up to Fox News, NBC News and all the giants. Lester Holt looks like he speaks with a pinch of tobacco in his lip. His tongue is always in the way. Some like Fox’s Outnumbered Lisa Kennedy not only has the lisp but the facial expressions are beyond annoying. You end up losing focus on the subject matter because the lisp and expressions are so distracting.
I just wonder if there has ever been a multi-million dollar government study done on how many of these women had tongue piercings at younger ages. It seems that I notice the same strong lisps in many of the girls that have these piercings. Does it become a habit after the piercing is removed? The girls say they talk like that because the bar in their tongue hits their teeth. When you watch most of these women they seem to have a problem talking because their tongue is always getting in the way. Plus during the recent years in school, I often heard how cute it was when a girl had a lisp. When did it come to this? How did it become cute now instead of unacceptable? I remember schools used to put kids in speech classes when they had impediments. I don’t even know if schools have that anymore. Millions get pumped into sports and buying computers but yet something like speech therapy gets ignored. I guess it’s a sign of how nobody talks anymore which is why social media and texting is the only ways kids talk to each other anymore.
Anyway, you’d think the major networks would be more selective with the people they pick to put in front of a camera or on microphone. It seriously does distract people from the major news when you’re drawn to the speech impediment instead. I’m guessing they are all afraid of the lawsuit that would come if they stopped these people from getting their equal opportunity.
I just wish we weren’t forced to listen to these people because of the threat of lawsuits. I don’t want my kids growing up hearing this and thinking it’s an acceptable way to speak.

Comment from Brother Jonah   (IP: 75.71.247.180)
Time: September 11, 2017, 3:13 pm

Much like texting kills any skills in writing the English language. Chinese is more a written language. I got burned myself saying ni hao mah which is “hello” only more formal. Something in the compound vowel in hao. I think. Never been to China but in the states they’re really polite about non-Chinese people mispronouncing something. My mom was in Taiwan on the island Formosa. Which had a lot of people who were from far flung corners of the old Empire. And the spoken language was many dialects that are as neatly similar as German is to French. She said people would hold out their dominant hand and use the finger as a ‘stylus’ and the palm the slate. And write out the pictographs one by one. And it worked because the writing is standardized. Grimm’s law is the mathematic representation of the decay of language, really evolution into another or several other language(s). The Brothers Grimm codified it, without using a computer. I wouldn’t be able to do it WITH a computer. Some phrases that defeat modern English speakers show a pattern, like the term Spit’n’ image which is three words, not two, and it has nothing to do with spitting. It’s short for Spirit And Image and reflects the Druidic/Pictish religious beliefs regarding reincarnation. Being the spit’n’image of Great Grandpa means you look like him and have his personality as well. Regional or generational differences might not be the sources of the problems, but it pushes it along. If you heard me speaking like this you’d come away with the notion that I was mentally ill and possibly dangerous. And ignorant. The problem is well and thoroughly discussed here, but one thing is left out… a solution. English is said to be the most complex language there is. When the right wing pundits demand that everybody speak english I have to chuckle a bit. Only partly because they don’t actually speak English very well. It’s the blind leading the blind. They complain but can’t force anything. That makes them become crazy. And they take advantage of the Golden Age of radio being long gone. Try finding a new radio that gets the A.M. band. The Music stations from my childhood are flooded with Rush and Mike Savage and other really stupid assholes who have only one redeeming character. They learned Radio Talk. The net worth of that is the number of people who learn how deeply disturbed Right Wing philosophy actually is. Puts me off my feed, yes it does.

Comment from Andrea Cousins   (IP: 162.245.143.115)
Time: November 18, 2017, 8:08 am

Wonderful to find others who feel this
way! Women broadcasters with Valley Girl accents, or female gravel voice, or who overintone, like girly-girl
caricatures. There is a new co-host of All Things Considered whose name I can’t understand and who speaks
with a terrible lisp. Who is this? And
why has NPR hired her for radio
broadcasting?

Write a comment